366 Weird Movies may earn commissions from purchases made through product links.
DIRECTED BY: Chris Walas
FEATURING: Bill Paxton, Marshall Bell, Michael Ironside, Marc McClure, Marci Kapture, Colleen Camp, Patrika Darbo
PLOT: A mild-mannered corporate drone reaches for his piece of the American Dream by purchasing a fixer-upper as a starter home, but it becomes a nightmare when a slovenly homeless man torments him into madness.
COMMENTS: I will always hold a place in my heart for Bill Paxton. His cornfed smile made him seem like a candidate for the most ordinary man ever to topline a Hollywood blockbuster, but his career thrived on his willingness to peel away the veneer of normality at a moment’s notice, revealing anything from aggressive cockiness to depraved sadism to lily-livered terror, sometimes all within the same character. So when considering an actor to embody a man walking the line between fresh-faced yuppie and borderline psychotic, Paxton is definitely your go-to guy.
In fact, he may be too on-the-nose for the part, because there’s never a moment where you’re wondering what’s going on with Paxton’s character, hard-working nebbish Graham Krakowski. All things seem possible, especially in a movie like The Vagrant which strives to be outrageous without any particular point to prove. It’s awkward to watch the water get hotter and hotter for Graham, but not uncomfortable, because we’re used to seeing Paxton in over his head. We’re watching to see just what mess he’s gotten himself into this time, and truth is… it’s not a very interesting one.
The first act unfolds in familiar sitcom fashion, as the grotesque home invader (kudos to the director’s brother Mark for the superbly hideous makeup) becomes ever more brazen and Graham grows ever more hapless. The script checks all the boxes for “a big misunderstanding,” as Paxton steadily works through alienating his girlfriend, his employer, and the Phoenix police department in his effort to rid himself of his unkempt stalker. Naturally, anyone who takes his side without reservation, from his addled neighbor to his nymphomaniac realtor, ends up savagely murdered. (This is to say nothing of his poor mom, who is taken down by overzealous authorities in court.) It plays like the most extreme version of a Hitchcockian wrong-man plot, as the punishment becomes geometrically more severe and Graham’s marbles escape with greater velocity.
However, once Graham loses everything, the movie runs out of places for him to go. Ironically, Paxton seems more at home hiding out in a rundown trailer park than he ever did as an aspiring upper-middle manager; the film seems to think that’s funny enough on its own. With the title character in hot pursuit, screenwriter Richard Jefferies flies in a late plot twist to try and explain everything, but all it really does is prove how far beyond its basic idea that this simple story has been stretched.
The shame of it is that Paxton is giving it his all, and he’s surrounded by a murderer’s row of C-list all-stars (The girl from Silk Stalkings! The guy from Not Necessarily the News! Jimmy Olsen!) who are given very little to do. Most underused is certainly Ironside, whose intimidating bluster is in full force, but without the wit or menace that gives it depth. Like the cast, the core idea is strong. When confronted with negative fantasies of a dangerous world, many a homeowner has imagined their domicile to be more prison than castle, and that principle has animated thrillers like Pacific Heights and Unlawful Entry. In the case of The Vagrant, the filmmakers are hoping that this idea is weird enough all by itself.
One never wants to bring box office into the mix, especially when considering films that deliberately shun the mainstream, but The Vagrant’s adventure in the cineplex is too remarkable to overlook: released on eight screens, it made $4,300 during its opening weekend before being yanked from theaters after eight days with a cumulative gross of $5,900. Friends, this movie was not exhibited so much as it was tossed from a moving car. It’s an apt fate, although one can never be too dismissive of a film that gives Bill Paxton one more chance to go a little whack-a-doodle. But when the rough is this deep, the diamond has to shine that much brighter.
WHAT THE CRITICS SAY:
(This movie was nominated for review by Parker Weston. Suggest a weird movie of your own here.)
Your observation that Paxton seems more at home in the trailer park than in his aspiring middle-class life suggests a sharper satire than the late explanatory twist allows. Does making the threat concrete ultimately let Graham off the hook, when the more unsettling possibility would be that his idea of home ownership is itself producing the nightmare? That tension seems especially relevant to your distinction between watching him become frantic and actually feeling uncomfortable.